Connect with us


Instant Reaction: Preseason Week 3

It’s safe to say that Week 3 of the NFL Preseason was a roller coaster of emotions for the fantasy football community. One minute we’re all watching Patrick Mahomes toss 60-plus yard touchdowns on perfectly executed wheel routes, and the next minute we all receive the notification on our phones that Andrew Luck has officially retired from the NFL. Flash forward five more minutes and we find out that Lamar Miller tore his ACL and is out for the 2019 season. In situations that lead to a rush of different emotions, it can sometimes be difficult to react without overreacting. That’s what I’m here for.

I took every top performer from this week of preseason football and sorted them into one of two groups. If I thought the player was already owned in nearly all dynasty formats, I listed their names in the following paragraph. If the player could possibly be on dynasty waiver wires (assuming 30 roster spots), they’ll be sorted into one of the following categories: “Add and stash”, “add and sell high”, or “leave on the waiver wire”. If I didn’t mention a player that you were hoping I’d include in this article, feel free to slide into my Twitter DMs (@DynastyFF_KyleM) and I’ll be happy to give you my thoughts on that player. Enjoy!

*Top Week 2 performers that should already be owned in all formats: Derrius Guice, J.J. Arcega-Whiteside, Chris Godwin, T.J. Hockenson, Dalvin Cook, Damien Williams.

Giants vs. Bengals (Thursday):

  • Rodney Anderson (CIN RB) – 12 touches, 58 yards

After landing in one of the most crowded running back corps in the NFL with later-than-expected draft capital, Anderson was cast aside by the majority of the dynasty community. However, with Gio Bernard’s free agency looming, we could see Anderson sliding into the “Joe Mixon handcuff”  role sooner rather than later.

Verdict: Add and stash

  • Damion Willis (CIN WR) – 3 receptions, 55 yards, 1 TD

Willis has put up back-to-back impressive performances this preseason, and he’s certainly taken the Bengals front office by notice. He was recently announced as the starter for the season opener, meaning that Willis could provide value as the potential WR2 in Cincinnati with A.J. Green on the shelf.

Verdict: Add and stash

Redskins vs. Falcons (Thursday):

  • Qadree Ollison (ATL RB) – 12 touches, 42 yards

Ollison continued his relatively high preseason usage, topping 40 yards on the ground in his third consecutive game. However, if you can find a league mate that believes Ollison will receive the majority of the workload if Freeman goes down with an injury, he’s a sell. While this outcome is possible, that backfield is too crowded and is proving to be impossible to predict.

Verdict: Add and sell high

Panthers vs. Patriots (Thursday):

  • Jakobi Meyers (NE WR) – 7 receptions, 74 yards

Meyers has been one of the most impressive offensive players through three weeks, but it’s important to consider the fact that the top three receivers on the New England depth chart have either been extremely limited or inactive thus far in the preseason. I’m not rushing to the trade block to sell Meyers, but if I find an owner that believes he has a shot at dethroning N’Keal Harry as the best rookie WR on the Patriots, I’m selling quickly.

Verdict: Add and sell high

  • Phillip Dorsett (NE WR) – 7 receptions, 47 yards

Dorsett hasn’t lived up to his first-round NFL Draft pedigree, but he’s been semi-productive since pairing up with Tom Brady. If available on the waiver, he’s certainly worth a stash in case the Josh Gordon saga takes a wrong turn.

Verdict: Add and stash

  • Nick Brossette (NE RB) – 14 touches, 53 yards

With Sony Michel, James White, and Damien Harris ahead of him on the depth chart, Brossette would need multiple injuries in order to become even remotely fantasy relevant.

Verdict: Leave on the waiver wire

Ravens vs. Eagles (Thursday):

  • Michael Floyd (BAL WR) – 3 receptions, 54 yards, 1 TD

We’ve all been down this road before. Floyd provides nothing more than depth in the Ravens wide receiver room, especially after Baltimore addressed this position twice within the first three rounds of the 2019 NFL Draft.

Verdict: Leave on the waiver wire

Jaguars vs. Dolphins (Thursday):

Source: PhinsCom on Twitter
  • Mike Gesicki (MIA TE) – 3 receptions, 59 yards

If Gesicki happens to be sitting on your waiver wire, minimize this article and go scoop him up. Young tight ends take time to develop, and while it may not be easy, we must be patient as dynasty owners.

Verdict: Add and stash

Packers vs. Raiders (Thursday):

  • Trevor Davis (GB WR) – 5 receptions, 78 yards, 1 TD

Davis posted one of the more impressive stat lines during Week 3 of the preseason but currently sitting behind Valdez-Scantling, Allison, and Kumerow on the depth chart, the path to targets would require too many injuries.

Verdict: Leave on the waiver wire

Browns vs. Buccaneers (Friday):

  • Dare Ogunbowale (TB RB) – 9 touches, 41 yards

Ogunbowale didn’t light the world on fire in this contest, but he’s a hot name in the dynasty community right now, so I figured I’d include him in this piece. He’s certainly worth an add after Ronald Jones suffered a preseason leg injury, but the hype seems to be getting out of control. Many are expecting Ogunbowale to seize the starting RB role in Tampa Bay, and I simply don’t see that happening.

Verdict: Add and sell high

Cardinals vs. Vikings (Saturday):

  • KeeSean Johnson (ARI WR) – 7 receptions, 85 yards

If KeeSean is somehow still on your dynasty waiver wire, it’s time to change that. He’s been repeatedly labeled as the best receiver in Cardinals training camp, and he’s building a fantastic rapport with Kyler Murray this offseason. Get your hands on him in dynasty before it’s too late.

Verdict: Add and stash

  • Mike Boone (MIN RB) – 11 touches, 47 yards, 1 TD

Boone has impressed throughout the entire preseason, and while I’m still convinced that Alexander Mattison will open the season as Dalvin’s direct backup, Boone is proving to be worth an add in case he’s able to outplay Mattison and lock down the backup role.

Verdict: Add and stash

Texans vs. Cowboys (Saturday):

  • Damarea Crockett (HOU RB) – 4 touches, 32 yards

Crockett didn’t necessarily impress with this performance, but I figured he needed to be included after Lamar Miller’s ACL injury. With so much uncertainty in that Houston backfield, Crockett is worth a stash in the off chance he’s able to carve out a significant role in 2019.

Verdict: Add and stash

Source: FanSided
  • Karan Higdon (HOU RB) – 13 touches, 28 yards

See Crockett, Damarea.

Verdict: Add and stash

  • Devin Smith (DAL WR) – 6 receptions, 79 yards

Smith has been plagued with injury ever since entering the league in 2015; however, he seems to finally be showing flashes this offseason in Dallas. Unfortunately, Smith is nothing more than WR depth behind at least five other weapons in that Cowboys passing game.

Verdict: Leave on the waiver wire

Bears vs. Colts (Saturday):

  • Charcandrick West (IND RB) – 16 touches, 70 yards, 1 TD

Even if Marlon Mack was to suffer an in-season injury, I’m confident the Colts would turn to some combination of Nyheim Hines and Jordan Wilkins before they decide to hand the reins over to West.

Verdict: Leave on the waiver wire

  • Deon Cain (IND WR) – 3 receptions, 74 yards, 1 TD

Cain picked up where he left off last week, continuing to show dynasty owners that he’s well on his way to putting his injury-riddled past behind him. The recent Andrew Luck news is obviously not great for Cain’s dynasty stock, but Jacoby Brissett has proven to be more than capable as a starter at the NFL level.

Verdict: Add and stash

Saints vs. Jets (Saturday):

  • Dan Arnold (NOTE) – 5 receptions, 83 yards

Before the Jared Cook signing, Arnold was an extremely late-round target of mine in dynasty startups. However, despite his impressive performance in his contest, there simply isn’t much value in a backup tight end in an offense that mainly targets two players.

Verdict: Leave on the waiver wire

49ers vs. Chiefs (Saturday):

  • Jeff Wilson Jr. (SF RB) – 12 touches, 45 yards, 2 TDs

Wilson proved to be a capable starter at times last season and didn’t disappoint in this contest either, but this San Francisco running back corps in the most crowded in the league. Not only is it unlikely for Wilson to make a sizable contribution to fantasy owners in 2019, but I wouldn’t be shocked if he’s cut from the SF roster once Jerick McKinnon returns from injury.

Verdict: Leave on the waiver wire

Steelers vs. Titans (Sunday):

Jeremy McNichols (TEN RB) – 9 touches, 43 yards

Despite showing flashes this preseason, McNichols is no higher than third on the Tennessee depth chart. Unless something happens to both Derrick Henry and Dion Lewis, McNichols should be ignored in dynasty leagues.

Verdict: Leave on the waiver wire

To consolidate this information into one list, here’s how I’d rank the top 10 aforementioned players in terms of dynasty value:

  1. Mike Gesicki
  2. KeeSean Johnson
  3. Jakobi Meyers
  4. Rodney Anderson
  5. Deon Cain
  6. Damarea Crockett
  7. Qadree Ollison
  8. Phillip Dorsett
  9. Karan Higdon
  10. Mike Boone

Thanks for reading, and as always, follow me on Twitter @DynastyFF_KyleM for more dynasty content! Become a member of the #NerdHerd for just $2.99 per month. Get Dynasty Nerds consensus rankings, buy/sell tool, extra podcasts, and more. 

I agree to have my personal information transfered to MailChimp ( more information )
Join over 10,000 subscribers and get updated on new podcast releases, private giveaways, new tools, mock drafts and more...
We hate spam. Your email address will not be sold or shared with anyone else.

Get the Edge – Join the #NERDHERD




More in Dynasty


Join the #NERDHERD and gain premuim access to - extra Weekly Podcast, Rankings, Film Room and more...
Terms and Conditions apply
Join #nerdherd