Dak Prescott vs. Patrick Mahomes.
When comparing NFL resumes, it would seem preposterous to even have a conversation. Give me Patrick Mahomes to start an NFL franchise ten out of ten times.
But, I am not a billionaire who owns an NFL franchise or even playing in Franchise Mode on Madden NFL 21. I am assembling the best fantasy football team that I can under the constraints of a salary cap.
In every salary cap league that I have seen, Prescott provides a better value to my team than Mahomes.
Patrick Mahomes has three seasons as a starting QB in the NFL. He exploded on the scene in 2018 with a season-long performance that many fantasy players aren’t likely to forget.
He finished with 542.1 fantasy points in the 2018 season with 5,097 yards, 52 total TDs, and 12 INTs, stats courtesy of Pro Football Reference. If you were able to snag him in a draft before the 2018 season at around 3-5% of the salary cap… congratulations! I hope you enjoyed your championship.
Predictably, the success from the 2018 season has caused his acquisition cost in startup drafts to rise from 3-5% to 15-18% or more. Some owners are comfortable spending that kind of budget on him because he can go out and win you a week by himself. He can carry you to a championship.
Dak Prescott has earned two Pro Bowl nods in his career. He progressed each season from 2017 through the start of 2020. Before his injury in Week 5 against the Giants, Prescott was on pace to score 560 fantasy points in 2020. His progression from 2018 to 2019 is the most staggering. He threw for over 1,000 more yards and eight more TDs in 2019 compared to 2018.
After his 2019 season, he was viewed as a tier two QB alongside Deshaun Watson, Russel Wilson, and Kyler Murray. He could be had for 4-6% of the salary cap.
He started 2020 on fire and was on pace for 6,599 passing yards. While I may be an eternal optimist, I think it is safe to say that he was not breaking Peyton Manning’s single-season passing yards record by more than 1,100 yards.
For a fair comparison of 2020 seasons, Prescott scored 159.1 points in 4.5 games for 35.36 points per game before his injury. Per Pro Football Reference, Prescott had 1,856 yards, 13 total TDs, and 4 INTs, in 4.5 games. I have taken his stats and regressed them by 20% to project out his final stat line if he played a full 16 game schedule.
In the chart below, the 2019 seasons were nearly identical from a point per game perspective, and the projected difference in 2020 was only 2.20 points per game in favor of Mahomes. The difference comes when comparing the points scored per dollar invested. You would have been rewarded with a 3.45x return on Prescott compared to Mahomes in 2019 and a projected 2.99x return in 2020, if not for his injury.
If you want to build a team that can be flexible and adapts to the draft or dynasty offseason, then don’t spend big at QB. Getting a tier two QB will result in nearly the same amount of points per game. It also allows you much more roster construction flexibility and more leniency when it comes to your mid-round picks and later-round fliers.
I’ll take Prescott at five percent of the budget over Mahomes and his cost of 15 percent. This strategy allows me to use the ten percent I am not spending on a QB on a Travis Kelce, George Kittle, or Darren Waller. This is how to dominate in salary cap leagues!
Did you hear the big news? The Dynasty Nerds youtube channel is up and running. Now you can see the podcast straight from the NerdHQ!! Smash that subscribe button. Sign up for the DynastyGM tool to keep that edge over your leaguemates. Manage all of your dynasty teams, use the trade calculator, and we just added a player shares tool so you can see all players you roster in one place. Try it here for free.
Get the Edge – Join the #NERDHERD
- Dynasty Nerds Logo Sticker 3.99$ – 4.49$
- #Nerdherd Members Only - American Apparel T-Shirt 28.99$ – 32.99$
- Boxer Briefs 29.95$ – 32.45$
- Dynasty Nerds - Champion Hoodie 54.99$ – 56.99$
- #Nerdherd Pennant/Front and Badge/Back - American Apparel T-Shirt 32.00$ – 36.50$