Close this search box.
Fantasy Football Dynasty/Keeper rankings

Case Study: Dynasty Trades HQ Listener League – Productive Struggle Part 3

Have you ever wondered what went into creating a championship team? Over the next month, @JSnake_DFF will go through how he turned a team into a championship contender in two years. Here’s part 3: The Rookie Draft

In part 3 of my Superflex dynasty case study, I will discuss the trades and draft picks I made during the 2021 offseason. As a reminder, I drafted this team with a productive struggle mindset. If you want to read part 1 about the start-up draft, click here. For part 2 about the moves made in the first season, click here.

One important update for this series is that my draft picks after the first season ended up being 1.02, 2.02, and 3.02, BUT if you remember, I also had a trade during the start-up that ended up giving me the 1.01, 2.01, and 3.01 so the future is BRIGHT.

Going into the draft season I had the 1.01, 1.02, 1.07, 1.09, 1.11, 2.01, 2.02, 2.07, 2.08, & 3.01. So I was stoked for draft season! But before we get to the draft, I made two trades that we need to talk about.

Superflex Dynasty Regular Season: January-August 2021

Traded Deebo Samuel, Darnell Mooney, & Austin Hooper FOR Amari Cooper, JJ Taylor, & Jalen Guyton

My first trade looks REALLY bad with hindsight, but at the time, I was making a move for the Dak and Amari Cooper stack. A couple of things I should have thought about before making this move is:

  1. The production that Dak sustained during his healthy games in 2020 was not sustainable, and valuing offensive weapons based on that thought was bad process.
  2. The Cowboys had Ceedee Lamb on their team, who is arguably a better WR. He also scored more points than Amari Cooper in 2021 and will most likely continue to do so.
  3. By not getting another decent asset, I gave myself too much risk in moving three decent players for one good player. I should have pushed for a player in the range of a 2021 second in value and not two roster cloggers.

I made this trade to push for a championship too soon instead of holding onto my high upside assets like Deebo and Mooney. This is a good reminder never to rush to compete, and instead, be patient and always act like you are retooling, especially in dynasty.

Traded 2021 1.02 & 2.07 FOR AJ Brown

AJ Brown fantasy
AJ Brown (Wesley Hitt/Getty Images)

Some people may hate this trade, but it ended up being Trey Lance & Amon Ra St. Brown FOR AJ Brown. The main reason I was comfortable making this move is I love the athleticism and scoring potential of AJ Brown, and I already had the 1.01 and planned to draft Trevor Lawrence. My QBs after drafting the 1.01 would be Mahomes, Dak Prescott, and TLaw. I would put this trade as an even one with both sides winning even now, being a year out. Also, AJ Brown’s 36.5 fantasy point Week 16 performance did lead me to advance and win the title in this league!


After the two trades, I still have 6 of the first 14 picks. When I draft, I usually follow the best player available mantra and have found that when I don’t, I get burned. So let’s get to the picks.

1.01- Trevor Lawrence

TLaw was the consensus 1.01, and I agreed with that evaluation. He struggled in 2021, but I still have hope and plan on holding onto him. He is a solid dynasty piece, especially in SF leagues.

1.07- Ja’Marr Chase

Photo by Joe Sargent/Getty Images
Photo by Joe Sargent/Getty Images

Chase was a steal at 1.07, and I was ecstatic to draft him there. He had his value increase the most out of any rookie player in the draft, and he helped lead me to a championship win in week 17 with 64.6 fantasy points. I will be holding onto Chase forever on this dynasty team! Drafting a player like Chase in rookie drafts is what will truly catapult a productive struggle draft! Also, a fun thing to look at is the change in dynasty value, and according to, he went from their WR12 to their WR2.

1.09- Javonte Williams

Javonte Williams was another player that I was happy to draft. I did not know how well he would perform in 2021, but he proved to have weeks of an explosion in points, while others were lackluster. The best part about drafting Williams for my team is his dynasty value skyrocketed. According to Dynasty Trade Calculator, he went from their 21st ranked RB to their 4th at the end of the 2021 season. Again, drafting high-rise assets is why rookie draft picks are the easiest way to quickly accrue a lot of team value.

1.11- Jaylen Waddle

Waddle was an example of drafting BPA. I did not expect much from him going into the 2021 season, but boy did he end up being a key part of my championship run. Back during the draft, had him as their WR27, and now he is WR10. I was lucky to be 4/4 with my draft picks so far.

2.01- Rashod Bateman

Credit: Shawn Hubbard | Baltimore Ravens Photos

Now to go for 5/5. Bateman was another BPA pick and saw his value rise over the 2021 season, and he even had some use in the starting lineup. He went from the WR34 when drafted and is now listed as the WR20. So, after just five picks, I ended up setting up the backbone of my dynasty team for years to come with a core set of players, including Patrick Mahomes, Dak Prescott, AJ Brown, Diontae Johnson, and Amari Cooper.

2.02- Trey Sermon

So this is where things started to go downhill. I decided to draft for team needs instead of sticking with BPA. Sermon had a ton of hype after the NFL draft. I thought I had a solid RB2 for years to come, especially after the 49ers spent a third-round pick on him. Well, now we know I should have picked either Elijah Moore or Rondale Moore, but live and learn.

2.08- Kadarius Toney

Toney was an interesting pick for me at 2.08, especially with his first-round draft capital. I again did not expect much from him going into 2021, and tbh he didn’t do much. I was able to use Toney in a trade that set up my team to make a playoff run!

3.01- Kyle Trask

Trask was a dart throw QB that I was hoping would turn into something. He was a second-round pick, which is a promising draft capital for a QB. In general, third-round picks are dart throws, so this was a swing and a miss pick.


As you can see, my team’s talent has exploded after the rookie draft. I knew my team was better, but I still was skeptical about how good we would be going into the 2021 season. “In hindsight, adding Javonte Williams, Ja’Marr Chase, Jaylen Waddle, and Rashod Bateman would do the trick!


  1. One thing that is important to remember is that the 2021 draft class was EXCELLENT, so I had fewer chances to miss than other draft classes. I think it is important to focus on the draft class the next offseason after drafting, and the 2023 draft class is looking to be similar in talent to the 2021 class. So this offseason feels like another great time to have a productive struggle draft!
  2. Do not be afraid to move rookie picks for known talent, especially if you feel like the player you are receiving has secure value. AJ Brown has maintained his value pretty well over the season and helped my team when it counted.
  3. I was fortunate with how many of my picks hit, especially with how normal hit rates look, so I would always plan to need another year to win a ship. But don’t be afraid to make a couple of moves for solid players to make your team as competitive as possible in the playoffs if you are playoff-bound (more on this in part 4).

In part 4, I will talk about the trades and waiver adds I made in the 2021 season, which set my team to win the championship!


Get ready for your rookie draft with the DynastyGM!! Rankins, trade calculator, league analyzer, and much more. Just $4.99/month or better yet, bundle with the Nerd Herd for just $6.99/month and get extra podcasts, the Dynasty Prospect Film Room, and more.

Share on Social

More to read


Rank Name Position Pos. Rank


Dominate your Dynasty leagues

Dynasty Nerds App is Mission Control for your Dynasty Leagues. Download Now!

Dominate your
Dynasty leagues

Dynasty Nerds App is Mission Control for your Dynasty Leagues. Download Now!

Black Friday Sale

25% OFF 

Coupon Code - holiday25
Sign-up Now
* Terms & Conditions Apply

Log In

Not a member yet?