Close this search box.

How NFL Draft Selection Predicts Fantasy Rookie Success

What does history say about the landing spot in the NFL draft of your favorite rookie hopefuls?

It’s no secret that the order of the NFL draft is the single best quantifiable predictor of fantasy success to budding NFL players. It’s a rare moment in which NFL teams have no choice but to provide their unadulterated opinion on the value and fit of any individual player. But after obtaining this information from NFL GM’s, any commentary from team management is clouded and often equivocal. Much like driving a new car out of the lot immediately reduces its value, the same thing occurs with regard to a team’s public stance on a player once they leave the draft room. But the NFL draft cannot hide a team’s intentions. It acts as a prism into the thoughts of NFL GM’s before they leave the lot. And you as a dynasty owner can leverage this to improve your dyansty team.

After studying the data going back to 2000, I looked over some positional trends relating to draft selection. Given that the 2020 draft is now complete, let’s explore these differences and use this to provide some clarity as far as which player’s chances of becoming stars were or were not necessarily hurt by the results of the draft.

Defining a successful draft pick

To determine how successful a fantasy player was in his first four years in the league, I developed a modified median-like approach. I simply took each player’s second best season of those four and used that as the metric. This is preferable to straight average because it doesn’t unduly penalize players who might have had one abnormally down year or suffered an injury causing them to drop into the bottom 100 or 200 at their position. With using second-best season as the metric, you know that you are getting at least this production in half of your first four years with any player. Here were the results:

The graph above plots what to expect out of each fantasy position based on how many rounds of data to correlate draft selection on. For instance, any dark navy blue plots took all Round 1 results since 2000 (per position) and correlated the exact selection number (1 – 32) on that player’s second-best seasonal position ranking.

For example: in 2016, Ezekiel Elliott was the fourth selection of Round 1 of the draft. In his first four years in the NFL, his second-best season finish was as the RB3. So for Elliott, his draft selection (4) is correlated to his second-best year (3). When we add the same two figures for all other running backs taken in the first round of the NFL draft since 2000, the resulting r-squared is less than 0.2, which indicates a very weak correlation (as indicated by the dark navy blue point for Running Backs.

That explains the navy blue grouping for Round 1. The next shade of blue down (representing players taken in Rounds 1 and 2) uses the exact same process; however, this grouping brings more data into the fold. In doing so, we can investigate if any meaningful differences exist across draft selections between Round 1 and Round 2. This same methodology is applied over larger groupings to eventually include all rounds of the draft. In doing so, the loss in fantasy value for each round added begins to appear for each position.

Let’s go position by position and find some takeaways we can leverage.


Main Takeaway

  • Top fantasy QBs go quick in the NFL draft. Taking chances on QBs from the back-end of round one or later is likely going to end in disappointment

The data shows that hit rates on QB fall drastically right off the bat in Round 1. We know this because there is a pretty high correlation between fantasy success and draft selection number when only considering Round 1 data since the year 2000. A higher selection (lower number) in the first round is going to do much better than a later selection (higher number).

It might not be surprising to learn top drafted QBs are starkly better than later selections but the graph better demonstrates its magnitude. The difference between taking a QB drafted in the top of Round 1 vs the bottom part of Round 1 is on par with the difference in taking a Round 1 RB vs a Round 6. That’s how picked over QB becomes at the back-end of the first round.

2020 prospects like Joe Burrow and Tua Tagovailoa were both expected to be nabbed high in the first round // Round 1. However, Justin Herbert was not, yet landed soon after at selection #6. While film room scouts might have credible reasons to heed expectations for Herbert, draft position alone suggests he has a chance for some level of success in his first four years. After Herbert (at most), the data suggests taking chances on any of the guys listed below to be a complete shot in the dark. This means that Jordan Love is not a great bet to take a chance on. Just because Aaron Rodgers was a successful late Round 1 selection doesn’t mean history is going to repeat itself.

Running Backs

Main Takeaways

  • The selection of a running back in round one of the NFL draft is not important, so long as he’s taken there. Definitely take chances on RBs after round one, but don’t expect the world.
  • Note that in recent years, NFL teams are starting to devalue the running back in the draft; so don’t be too wary of the plethora of second round drafted RB talent this year.

Running Backs and Quarterbacks have polar opposite round one implications: while the data highlights the importance of where a Quarterback is selected in Round 1, the particular selection an RB is taken in Round 1 means almost nothing (r = .15). In other words, it matters very little where in Round 1 a Running Back is selected. What matters most is that the Running Back IS selected in Round 1. One possible explanation for this is that the gap in talent from the first few Quarterbacks and the rest is so massive. There’s a reason it’s the most important position in sports.

Take a look at the rest of the running back plots. As you extend the data to include more rounds, the correlation grows. Running backs taken in later rounds are increasingly less likely to add any value to dynasty owners. There simply aren’t that many diamonds in the rough at the running back position. And as far as the running back goes in real football, the skill set of practically any running back is basically irrelevant in determining his production on the field. Instead, it’s the commitment from his team to put him in a position to produce. And this commitment is revealed by the draft capital spent.

This data backs up the hype on Clyde Edwards-Helaire (CEH). While considered a much lesser talent than many other RBs in his draft class, him being taken as the first pick for the Chiefs reveals that Brett Veach and Andy Reid are going to fit the offense around CEH, as apposed to the other way around. The fact that Kansas City is a perfect landing spot for a pass-catching RB is icing on the cake. The talent level is practically irrelevant.

Take a quick look at the 2020 running back draft class:

Position Player Round Pick Team
RB Clyde Edwards-Helaire 1 32 KAN
RB D’Andre Swift 2 35 DET
RB Jonathan Taylor 2 41 IND
RB Cam Akers 2 52 LAR
RB J.K. Dobbins 2 55 BAL
RB AJ Dillon 2 62 GNB
RB Antonio Gibson 3 66 WAS
RB Ke’Shawn Vaughn 3 76 TAM
RB Zack Moss 3 86 BUF
RB Darrynton Evans 3 93 TEN
RB Joshua Kelley 4 112 LAC
RB La’Mical Perine 4 120 NYJ
RB Anthony McFarland Jr. 4 124 PIT
RB DeeJay Dallas 4 144 SEA
RB Jason Huntley 5 172 DET
RB Eno Benjamin 7 222 ARI
RB Raymond Calais 7 245 TAM
RB Malcolm Perry 7 246 MIA

Historically speaking, anyone taken in Round 2 becomes a higher risk than round those taken in Round 1. This is where things get a little weird because in recent years the NFL has slowly begun to embrace the reality that top-skilled running backs provide little worth to NFL teams over those of average skill. So teams that might have taken a running back in round one – even just a few years ago – might wait until round two or even later. So when you look at the names drafted above in Round 2 of the 2020 draft, there is a lot of potential for one or more of these guys to be competing for the overall RB1 rank sometime in the next four years. Get as many of these second rounders as you can.

Wide Receiver / Tight End

Main Takeaways

  • Focus on receivers taken in round one or two only and don’t worry about the particular selection.
  • Don’t bother with tight ends after round one. You’d need to get stupid lucky to find the next Gronkowski. For 2020 purposes…go ahead and punt on this position.

Much like running back, as every additional round of the draft is added to the analysis, the correlation grows. But a key difference exists at the “Rounds 1 – 2” slice. Wide receivers taken in round two are historically much better bets than running backs taken in round two (vs their round one competition). I’ve given my reason to not fear round two running backs in 2020, and I offer the same advice for receivers.

Here is the wide receiver class now for 2020:

Position Player Round Pick Team
WR Henry Ruggs III 1 12 VEG
WR Jerry Jeudy 1 15 DEN
WR CeeDee Lamb 1 17 DAL
WR Jalen Reagor 1 21 PHI
WR Justin Jefferson 1 22 MIN
WR Brandon Aiyuk 1 25 SFO
WR Tee Higgins 2 33 CIN
WR Michael Pittman Jr. 2 34 IND
WR Laviska Shenault Jr. 2 42 JAX
WR KJ Hamler 2 46 DEN
WR Chase Claypool 2 49 PIT
WR Van Jefferson 2 57 LAR
WR Denzel Mims 2 59 NYJ
WR Lynn Bowden Jr. 3 80 VEG
WR Bryan Edwards 3 81 VEG
WR Devin Duvernay 3 92 BAL
WR Gabriel Davis 4 128 BUF
WR Antonio Gandy-Golden 4 142 WAS
WR Joe Reed 5 151 LAC
WR Tyler Johnson 5 161 TAM
WR Collin Johnson 5 165 JAX
WR Quintez Cephus 5 166 DET
WR John Hightower 5 168 PHI
WR Isaiah Coulter 5 171 HOU
WR Darnell Mooney 5 173 CHI
WR K.J. Osborn 5 176 MIN
WR Donovan Peoples-Jones 6 187 CLE
WR Quez Watkins 6 200 PHI
WR James Proche 6 201 BAL
WR Isaiah Hodgins 6 207 BUF
WR Dezmon Patmon 6 212 IND
WR Freddie Swain 6 214 SEA
WR Jauan Jennings 7 217 SFO
WR K.J. Hill 7 220 LAC
WR Tyrie Cleveland 7 252 DEN

Many figured CeeDee Lamb would be first off the boards for wide receiver, but instead he landed third. The data suggests this is not a big deal. I would not be surprised if the Cowboys cut Cooper loose in the near future and turn this standout into a perennial WR1 in fantasy football. Even with Cooper’s new mega-deal, the particulars could give Dallas an out after this year.

Meanwhile, Henry Ruggs taken as the first off the board doesn’t necessarily increase his value as much as it might appear, just as Denzel Mims dropping further than expected doesn’t really hurt. The data does suggest to stay within these two players for fantasy relevance. Anything past round two is going to be hard to find value; and after round three, it’s a complete crap-shoot.

As for tight ends, there’s no position with a greater drop in value after the first round. With that said, some of the best of the position blossomed from round two selections (Rob Gronkowski, Zach Ertz, Hunter Henry). But despite these few mega-studs at the tight end position, hitting the lottery on the next generation tight end is going to be very difficult to do outside of round one. But hey, if you feel being a hero, go on right ahead. Just have a back-up plan.

Position Player Round Pick Team
TE Cole Kmet 2 43 CHI
TE Devin Asiasi 3 91 NWE
TE Josiah Deguara 3 94 GNB
TE Dalton Keene 3 101 NWE
TE Adam Trautman 3 105 NOR
TE Harrison Bryant 4 115 CLE
TE Albert Okwuegbunam 4 118 DEN
TE Colby Parkinson 4 133 SEA
TE Brycen Hopkins 4 136 LAR
TE Charlie Woerner 6 190 SFO
TE Tyler Davis 6 206 JAX
TE Stephen Sullivan 7 251 SEA

All in all, much of what the data gleans already match general consensus, but visualizing the effect that later rounds have on fantasy outlooks across each position is something I feel every dynasty owner should understand in order to take educated chances on the NFL’s next generation. .

Share on Social

More to read

UNlock Premium For Free

Deposit at least $10 at Underdog Fantasy and get our #Nerdherd and DynastyGM FREE for 12 Months!
Use code Nerds at checkout!
* Restrictions Apply | New Users Only


Rank Name Position Pos. Rank


Dominate your Dynasty leagues

Dynasty Nerds App is Mission Control for your Dynasty Leagues. Download Now!

Dominate your
Dynasty leagues

Dynasty Nerds App is Mission Control for your Dynasty Leagues. Download Now!

Black Friday Sale

25% OFF 

Coupon Code - holiday25
Sign-up Now
* Terms & Conditions Apply

Log In

Not a member yet?