As we gear up for NFL free agency, the talk of the league is where QBs like Aaron Rodgers, Russell Wilson, Jimmy Garropolo, and (get this) Mitch Trubisky will be playing at the start of the 2022 season.
Teams like the Bucs, Saints, Broncos, Steelers, and Commanders are searching for QB help this offseason. Unless you have been living under a rock and not keeping up with our draft coverage on Dynasty Nerds, you should know that the 2022 class of rookie QBs isn’t getting many teams excited.
But what does all of this mean from a dynasty perspective? Specifically, what does this mean for the QB position on your rosters? We know a QB moving to another team impacts the WRs and RBs where he left and where he goes, but what is the landscape of the QB position right now overall?
Let’s take a look at the state of QBs in dynasty, why you should be holding them tighter than ever, and how highly you should be valuing them in startups.
The Pickings Continue to Thin
Coming into the 2021 season, the QB position seemed to get a significant boost from the 2021 rookie class. Five first-round quarterbacks gave hope to many dynasty owners, especially those searching for their next franchise guy.
Unfortunately, their rookie seasons were less than stellar.
Of the five rookies, only Mac Jones was able to finish in the top 36 (QB3 level) in PPG, and even then, Jones finished only 29th at 13.2 PPG. Trevor Lawrence and Zach Wilson finished tied 37th at 11.7 PPG, Justin Fields 43rd at 10.6 PPG, and Trey Lance only started in two games and finished with 10.8 PPG.
While the jury is still out on all five of these signal callers, and we shouldn’t be selling any of them yet, the herd has dwindled of premier QB talent in the NFL. Add to this that we have already seen Tom Brady (3rd in PPG in 2021) retire this offseason, and the pickings are starting to slim more and more every year.
With a less-than-exciting 2022 rookie class, the excitement for QBs in the lower tiers has to be dwindling for most dynasty owners, especially those in Superflex leagues.
In order to see this regression in clearer terms, I charted out the top-32 QBs in PPG for the last four NFL seasons (minimum six games played). The first step was figuring out how much lower each QB is scoring than the QB1 on the season. Second, I wanted to see how much lower QBs were scoring than the QB12 on the season (the end of the QB1s in a 12 team league).
Where this data gets interesting is in the second step. When we look at the scoring between QB12 and the QBs from 13 to 32, there is a much stronger drop-off in the most recent season. Here is a visualization of that data:
The white line that is charting the 2021 data points quickly dips from QB12 to QB16. In fact, no other line from any other season even reaches the 2021 line until we reach QB26.
Put another way. In 2018, there were 12 QBs from QB13-QB32 that scored over 15% lower than the QB12. In 2019 that number was only 9 QBs. 2020 saw only 7 QBs, more than 15% lower.
In 2021, 18 of the 20 QBs from QB13 to QB32 scored more than 15% less than the QB12. Of them, 11 QBs scored more than 25% lower than the QB12.
Judging by these numbers, we can see the 2021 season had more disparity than any other season in the last four years in QB totals.
In years past, we had QB tiers that saw premier talent, good starters, and spot start/bench players as the three main divides. Typically, guys in the top 5 to top 7 QBs were considered premier talents that give your team a boost, while the guys from 8 to 18 would be the quality starters.
Last season was very different.
Looking at the sheet above, after we reach QB14 (Jameis Winston), there is a steady drop in QB output. And look at the names associated with these numbers: Tannehill, Wentz, Garoppolo, Carr, Jones, Siemian, Bridgewater, and so on.
Imagine you are up in a startup Superflex draft. You have only one QB currently rostered, and you need to sure up the second QB. Is anyone standing out to you from QB14 to QB32? Maybe one of the rookies, but assuming they get drafted earlier due to their youth, how are you choosing in this tier?
All of this is to say that the separation in QB talent in the NFL is substantial, and it only feels like it is getting bigger.
Tom Brady has just retired from the NFL this offseason. Ben Roethlisberger (though awful in 2021) has done the same. Aaron Rodgers continues to threaten that retirement is not so far away, whether this year or over the next few seasons.
And while these QBs continue to bow out, the NFL youth influx has been hitting at every position in dynasty but QB. Right now, any young QB from 2021 or the incoming 2022 class is still a big question mark.
If you are already in an established league and are hunting for QB help, it is hard to say where you can turn. The pickings are slim in the current mid-tier of QBs, and the rookie class this season doesn’t look overly promising.
Anyone holding a top-tier QB should be valuing them through the roof. There is no reason to want to move any of these QBs right now as they are such a leg up on any of the other teams in your league.
Meanwhile, there are startup drafts. And this may be the biggest word of warning here. If you are in a Superflex startup draft, you have to be aware of how slim the pickings are at QB in the NFL right now. Truthfully, anyone in a Superflex startup should have two QBs drafted within their first three picks if they can.
Top-tier talent will continue to go fast in any startup draft. But you have to be aware that when the available names start to become more pedestrian, you should still be acting fast. An average QB in that moment will look great compared to what is coming as the drop off continues.
While this should all be taken as a warning more than a sure thing, I do genuinely worry that the lack of depth at QB league-wide will start to impact your dynasty leagues a great deal. Especially in Superflex.
While many of us in the dynasty community are talking poorly about this particular rookie QB crop, we need to consider the larger picture here: there are not many quality QBs available in your leagues anymore.
While future classes could bring in more premier talent and there is still a chance we get a stud out of the 2021 and 2022 classes, we are also seeing more careers nearing their end. Matt Ryan will be 37 this coming season. Ryan Tannehill and Russel Wilson will be 34 at the end of the 2022 campaign. Rodgers is 38 and talking about retirement.
If you currently have two good QBs on your team, they should be close to untouchable for you. If you are rebuilding and have a good QB to move, you should be asking for the moon.
And if you are joining a dynasty startup, QB should be high priority.
There are not that many fish in the sea.
Get ready for your rookie draft with the DynastyGM!! Rankins, trade calculator, league analyzer, and much more. Just $4.99/month or better yet, bundle with the Nerd Herd for just $6.99/month and get extra podcasts, the Dynasty Prospect Film Room, and more.